Hiring an in-house marketing manager and working with a marketing agency both have benefits, and for larger organisations it is generally not a case of one or the other. Often the in-house marketing team works with outsourced marketing specialists for digital advertising, photography and video production. For small to medium businesses that have tried an in-house model and are struggling to recruit the right people in the current market, though, it is a good time to evaluate an outsourced marketing department. In this article, we compare both models and what a similar budget for an in-house marketing manager might be spent on, with an outsourced solution.
Option 1: What does an in-house marketing manager do?
Let us look at a fairly typical Seek advert for an in-house marketing manager. Advertised at $90,000 to $110,000 plus benefits, a marketing manager at this level would be expected to lead the organisation’s brand, develop marketing content and manage a company’s social channels and digital platforms. If they are the only marketing resource, they commonly write and schedule social posts, develop campaign ideas, and manage influencers and partnerships, all while capturing content as it happens. On top of that, they should be reviewing and reporting on marketing performance to the manager or owner of the business, to inform future business goals and marketing spend.
That is strategy, copywriting, design, community management, PR, project management and data analysis all in one job. Few people are equally strong at all of these skills, and those who are, can be hard to find.
Biggest advantage of an in-house marketer
An in-house marketer is on the ground and sees the event setting up, the new product arriving and the team celebrating a win, and they can capture it as it happens. That kind of content is hard to recreate later, and we know the value of this first-hand. Content capture days for us are pre-scheduled and only work when we have the right people and the right products there to capture. Sometimes the best content is the photo or video we were not expecting, that on-the-fly moment when someone does something unexpectedly funny or clever.
In recent years, though, this advantage has reduced, because it relies on your marketing manager being on site with an on-site team. Most of our clients, and ourselves too, have remote or hybrid teams, or simply large teams that work different shifts, so it is rare for an in-house marketing person to be in the same place as the action anyway.
Where an in-house hire can be limiting
One person holds your marketing knowledge, your logins and your relationships. When they take leave or move on, the work slows or stops, and finding a replacement takes time and money.
It also does not work well when a business needs flexibility. For example, this quarter the focus might be on brand awareness through organic social content and a website refresh, but next quarter, as a new product launches, the focus might need to shift to a paid digital ads campaign. That pivot is a huge ask of one skill set, so businesses often end up focusing on what the marketing team can do, not what the business needs.
Option 2: Same budget, outsourced marketing department
The biggest advantage of an outsourced marketing department, for the same budget you would have spent on an in-house marketing manager, is the breadth of skills and services, and the freedom to change them as your business changes. A marketing department brings strategy, copywriting, design, photography and video, social media, email, paid advertising, website support and reporting under one roof.
A product launch might need more design and video. A quiet stretch might call for more email and social content. A big event might need media and PR. The mix shifts, and nobody has to be hired or let go to make it happen.
What the same budget can get you with an agency
Because a marketing agency works across many clients, with a shared team of specialists, the same budget can stretch further than it typically would for a single in-house hire. A typical $110,000 budget for the year commonly includes:
- Annual marketing workshop and plan. Planning, staff training and strategy advice.
- Monthly project management. One point of contact who keeps everything moving.
- Content capturing. Photo and video at your premises twice a month.
- Social media. A full content schedule, planned and written for every platform.
- Email marketing. A monthly enews, researched, written and loaded ready to send.
- Website maintenance and content. Regular content and technical updates to keep your site current for customers, and secure and performing well on the backend.
- Campaigns and ads. Three to four seasonal campaigns a year, plus always-on Google and Meta advertising, excluding ad spend.
- Design, print and video. Graphic design, print coordination and a video shoot when the plan calls for it.
- Reporting. A live marketing dashboard and regular updates, so you can see how your marketing is performing without manual analysis or report compilation.
There is a limit here too, our content capture visits are scheduled. We can be at your premises twice a month, but we cannot be there for that ad hoc blooper or unexpected moment the delivery truck arrives with a new product.
The two options side by side
| What your marketing needs | In-house marketing manager | Outsourced marketing department |
| Presence in your business | On site every day, capturing moments as they happen | Scheduled on-site visits and regular meetings |
| Knowledge of your business | Built up day by day | Built through planning workshops and regular contact |
| Range of skills | The strengths of one person | Strategy, writing, design, video, ads, email, web and reporting in one team |
| Changing needs | A new skill means a new hire or outside help | The mix of services changes as your needs do |
| When someone is away | Work slows or stops | Another team member steps in |
| Getting started | Recruitment comes first | A plan comes first – depending on the business’s needs, this could be a marketing plan, content plan, media plan or integrated digital ads plan |
How do you choose?
- Content in the moment. If your best content happens on site and your marketer would be there for it, an in-house hire is a strong choice.
- A changing list of skills. If your business needs require your marketing to be flexible, moving between content, design, video, ads, email and PR throughout the year, a team gives you more range.
- Coverage. Think about who does the work when your marketer is away or leaves?
- A mix of both. Some organisations keep an in-house lead for day-to-day presence and bring in an agency for specialist work.
If you are weighing this up, we are happy to talk it through, even workshop your ideas. Tell us about your business through our new client enquiry form.